When Legal Accountability Isn't Emotional Accountability: Healing After Infidelity in an Open Marriage

When Infidelity in an Open Marriage Leads to Divorce

“There's so much misinformation about divorce in general, but especially for queer, polyamorous, or people in nontraditional relationships. It's like, well, what rights do you have? Where can you get accountability for the betrayal?”

Cody is a busy corporate executive balancing a demanding career, an active social life, two children, and several hobbies. He has also identified as polyamorous for many years, an identity he and his husband had begun to more fully embody in their marriage.

But when Cody's marriage ended after his husband broke one of their relationship agreements, the experience became more complicated than he anticipated. They had agreed that outside relationships would be strictly sexual. When his husband developed an emotional connection with another partner, Cody experienced it as a breach of their agreement and a betrayal of trust.

As he navigated divorce, Cody spent considerable time seeking accountability for what had happened. But he often found himself looking for that accountability in places that couldn't fully hold the emotional weight of his experience. At times, he also found himself relying on his attorney for emotional support while trying to make sense of the betrayal and understand what the legal system could actually do.

The Limits of Legal Accountability After Infidelity

According to Anita Rojas Carroll, an attorney at Rower LLC, navigating divorce after infidelity in an open marriage can present unique challenges. One important consideration is the legal concept of wasteful dissipation. In many states, including New York, the burden of proof required to establish wasteful dissipation can be high. This can make it difficult for someone to obtain legal recognition of certain financial misconduct connected to a partner's infidelity.

In other words, even when someone experiences a profound breach of trust within their marriage, the legal system may not provide the kind of accountability they are looking for. The agreements that define a relationship, and the emotional harm caused when those agreements are broken, don't necessarily translate into legal claims or outcomes.

As a psychotherapist in private practice, I'm passionate about understanding the experiences of LGBTQIA+ people and people in nontraditional relationships navigating infidelity, separation, and divorce. Through conversations with people who have lived through these experiences, I've noticed a pattern that keeps coming up.

Because there are so many misconceptions about divorce, particularly in queer and polyamorous relationships, people may enter the process without a clear understanding of what to expect. They might assume that the legal system will recognize what happened, provide some form of accountability, and allow them to move forward feeling heard and validated.

But the legal process doesn't always work that way. And when the accountability someone hoped to find isn't there, another layer of grief can emerge, one that is often harder to name.

When the Legal System Recreates the Experience of Betrayal

For many people, naming infidelity in a queer or open relationship can already be challenging. They may worry that others won't understand their agreements, recognize the betrayal, or take their hurt seriously. When the legal system also requires a high burden of proof to establish certain claims, the experience can feel like another form of dismissal. It can even recreate the self-doubt and self-blame someone may have already experienced while trying to make sense of the betrayal.

Cody describes this experience:

“I feel like I'm going to bring this up and people are going to be dismissive because we are poly or people aren't going to believe me if I frame it in this way because again, we're poly. And so it feels like the legal system just replicated that. I'd say, oh, there was cheating, and everywhere people would say that didn't happen.”

When a relationship ends because of infidelity, people often hope that their community, their support systems, or the legal process will help them make sense of what happened. But when friends remain close with an ex, don't fully understand the betrayal, or when the legal system cannot provide the accountability someone is seeking, the person who was hurt can feel increasingly isolated at a time when they need support most.

The absence of legal accountability doesn't erase the harm someone experienced. And when the people or systems around them don't acknowledge that harm, it can become even harder to trust their own feelings and begin to heal.

So what happens when the legal system can't provide the recognition or accountability you hoped for?

It means finding other spaces where you can process what happened without having your experience minimized or rushed. It means allowing yourself to grieve what you've lost, make sense of the betrayal, and begin imagining the life you want to build next.

Here are three places to start.

1. Find support to hold the emotional side of infidelity.

Lawyers and the legal system play an important role in helping people navigate separation and divorce. But they aren't necessarily equipped to hold the emotional pain that comes with betrayal in queer and polyamorous relationships.

When the legal process can't provide the acknowledgment or accountability you're looking for, you may need a separate space to talk about what happened, cry, feel angry, and make sense of your experience without having to focus on legal strategy or the next steps in your case.

2. Seek support and validation from your community.

Find and lean on people who can hold space for your experience without minimizing it or pressuring you to move on before you're ready. Trusted friends, affirming queer communities, and divorce support groups can help you feel less alone as you navigate the complicated emotions of divorce and changes in your social world.

You deserve relationships where you don't have to constantly explain why what happened hurt you or defend the validity of your feelings.

3. Set boundaries with people who don't understand.

Not everyone will understand the depth of your betrayal or respond in the way you hoped. Some people may minimize what happened, encourage you to move on before you're ready, or expect you to maintain relationships that feel painful or overwhelming.

You are allowed to set boundaries around what you share, how much contact you have with certain people, and which social situations you're ready to navigate. You can take space from friendships that leave you feeling unsupported without having to make a permanent decision about those relationships.

Next
Next

When Betrayal Sends You Into Survival Mode: Healing After Infidelity in a Queer Marriage